Remembering Henry Kissinger
Do Leftists Even Understand Why They Hate Kissinger?
Henry Kissinger has died, and predictably, leftists have been crassly celebrating his death. If they give a reason at all, it's usually some reference to Cambodia, such as this one below, or less frequently, Chile.
Bourdain said all that needs to be said about Henry Kissinger https://t.co/UOYdouuN0j pic.twitter.com/Qk7FCKlOtm
— Wu Tang is for the Children (@WUTangKids) November 29, 2023
In Cambodia, Kissinger supported Nixon's bombing campaign of the North Vietnamese Army's supply lines into South Vietnam, a campaign which helped defeat the NVA insurgency in South Vietnam and bring North Vietnam to the negotiating table. That led to the Paris Peace Accords that extricated the U.S. from the Vietnam War (and likely would have maintained South Vietnam's independence had Nixon not been forced out in, effectively, an establishment coup in 1974: had Nixon been President in 1975, he would have used U.S. airpower to stop North Vietnam's mechanized invasion as he had in 1972).
The oddness of this leftist attack on Kissinger, combined with their relative silence about the communists who murdered millions of Cambodians in the 1970s, raises the question of whether they have confused Kissinger with Pol Pot, as one of our correspondents on X suggested below.
My own theory is that anger at Nixon/Kissinger over bombing Cambodia was so contemporary lib issue that somehow survived into the current day because people incorrectly conflate it with the Pol Pot-led genocide
— Future Moldovan Citizen (@MainstreamViews) November 30, 2023
Imagine seeing a wall of human skulls and your first thought is "I hate the guy who bombed the people who did this 5 years before they did it"
— Future Moldovan Citizen (@MainstreamViews) November 30, 2023
Our friend Sergei Witte, whom some of you may recall from his insightful posts on the Russia-Ukraine War, made a similar point.
People have a vague notion that they don’t like Henry Kissinger because the US bombed Cambodia, but the man was frequently an advocate for peace and sensible foreign policy. American relations with the USSR and China improved dramatically thanks to his efforts.
— Big Serge ☦️🇺🇸🇷🇺 (@witte_sergei) November 30, 2023
In the case of Chile, the leftist attacks on Kissinger make even less sense. He and Nixon backed Pinochet, who prevented a communist takeover of Chile, and put in place economic policies that made Chile the most stable country in South America for decades to come.
Respected More Abroad Than From Leftists At Home
Another friend of ours on X astutely predicted that we'd see more respect for Kissinger from non-leftists abroad than from leftists at home.
With few exceptions, the Chinese and Russian statements and appreciations (official, semi-official, and punditry) will probably be warmer, and have a greater depth and sense of history, than most of what we’ll see from their American equivalents. In death as in life I guess. RIP.
— St2station (@St2station) November 30, 2023
And he was soon proved correct, first by the popular Russian streamers behind RWApodcast...
Kissinger was what you'd call a "worthy adversary" I think. Certainly one of the most capable and level-headed diplomatic minds America has produced. Especially compared to the tacky imbeciles running the show in recent years. RIP
— Russians With Attitude (@RWApodcast) November 30, 2023
They don't make 'em like this anymore https://t.co/RZAWJ7gdJA
— Russians With Attitude (@RWApodcast) November 30, 2023
And then by the former Russian President, and current deputy head of Russia's National Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev,
Henry Kissinger has died. He has faithfully served his country for many years. At the same time, he was a pragmatist who took realities into consideration, and not just followed the US foreign policy canons. Now, there aren't even traces of the people like him in the US…
— Dmitry Medvedev (@MedvedevRussiaE) November 30, 2023
Here is the full text of Medvedev's post:
Henry Kissinger has died. He has faithfully served his country for many years. At the same time, he was a pragmatist who took realities into consideration, and not just followed the US foreign policy canons. Now, there aren't even traces of the people like him in the US Administration and the Western world. RIP
Similarly, the Australian naval officer, attorney, and foreign policy commentator Gray Connolly wrote respectfully of Kissinger,
Henry Kissinger was one of the true giants, as a historian, scholar, and diplomat, of the last century. Kissinger (with Nixon) inherited a poor US global position & a disastrous war, remediating both as best anyone could. His works will be read for centuries to come. HAK RIP. pic.twitter.com/H05desLCcA
— Gray Connolly (@GrayConnolly) November 30, 2023
Applying Today's Identity Politics To Kissinger
The New York Times and the ADL pointed out that Kissinger was America's first Jewish Secretary of State, while Hannah Gais implied that Kissinger was antisemitic based on a quip he made once about Jews.
goyim dont understand that this is THE most Jewish thing you could possibly say. https://t.co/2yoVXg2j2K
— Glinert 🇺🇸 🏭 (@StevenGlinert) November 30, 2023
Both miss the relevant point that Kissinger was Secretary of State when cabinet positions were appointed based on merit, and diplomats were expected to act in the interest of the United States, not their ethnic or religious group. Unlike our current Secretary of State, Antony Blinken, who while on a state visit to Israel last month talked about his Jewish ancestors' experience fleeing pogroms in the Russian Empire, Kissinger never saw himself as an advocate for his ethnic group, but for American policy. When he was asked about the plight of Soviet Jews in the 1970s, Kissinger said,
The emigration of Jews from the Soviet Union is not an objective of American foreign policy. And if they put Jews into gas chambers in the Soviet Union, it is not an American concern. Maybe a humanitarian concern.
Similarly, he was an even-handed negotiator in the Middle East, and famously bluffed the Israelis into releasing the Egyptian 3rd Army they had surrounded during the 1973 war by suggesting the Russians might intervene if they didn't.
We Are In Worse Hands Today
Compared to the men and women who have run our foreign policy this century, Kissinger was a giant, who presciently warned against provoking Russia in the Ukraine. Edward Hamilton highlighted the key contrast between Kissinger and the ideologues we have running the show today.
Kissinger's faults were mostly a matter of having very clearly defined goals and being willing to pursue them relentlessly, without regard to moral constraint.
— Edward L Hamilton (@EdwardLHamilton) November 30, 2023
Today we have the reverse fault: a surfeit of inflexible moral posturing oriented toward no achievable goals. https://t.co/Daf92v8d4V
Finally, even in his extreme old age, Kissinger understood the damage today's mass third world immigration was doing to the West.
Henry Kissinger: “It was a grave mistake to let in so many people of totally different cultures and religions” pic.twitter.com/pXnk2mm9xm
— ɖʀʊӄքǟ ӄʊռʟɛʏ 🇧🇹🇹🇩 (@kunley_drukpa) October 12, 2023
Let's hope his example and his wisdom on that inspires others.
In Case You Missed It
In a post earlier this week (Trading Update: Which Signals Are The Strongest Now?), we wrote about which signals were the strongest now in predicting stock movements post-earnings.
Trading Update: Which Signals Are The Strongest?
— Portfolio Armor (@PortfolioArmor) November 28, 2023
What our latest data says.https://t.co/MaOGeLW55u
As we mentioned there, we would be using the strongest signals to place earnings trades this week. We exited the first two of those earnings trades for gains of 66% and 78%, respectively, yesterday, and we exited the second two of those trades for gains of 39% and 106%, respectively, today. We have one more trade teed up for today, so if you're subscribed to our trading Substack/occasional email list, keep an eye on your inbox this afternoon. If you're not subscribed, you can subscribe below.
If You Want To Stay In Touch
You can scan for optimal hedges for individual securities, find our current top ten names, and create hedged portfolios on our website. You can also follow Portfolio Armor on Twitter here, or become a free subscriber to our trading Substack using the link below (we're using that for our occasional emails now).